The tale goes that photographer Miles Astray participated in the 1839 Color Photography Awards, a competition that encompassed various categories such as Architecture, Still Life, Film/Analog, as well as an AI-generated category that rewarded images not captured by a camera.
Astray chose to submit a genuine photograph taken with a camera for the AI-generated category, an entry titled “Flamingone,” featuring a photograph of a flamingo, and the verdict was that he clinched the 3rd prize from a panel of professional photographers from various organizations, while also attaining top votes as the crowd favorite.
Subsequently, Astray revealed that the flamingo picture was indeed captured with a real camera and not AI-generated, leading the competition organizers to revoke all his awards. The committee explained that while the photograph was powerful, each category had specific criteria, and the image deviated from the AI-generated category’s attributes, necessitating the withdrawal of his accolades out of respect for other participants.
The competition organizers expressed that this incident could raise awareness among professional photographers concerned about the encroachment of AI. Astray noted that AI has become a prominent topic in the creative industry and his experiment this time reaffirmed his belief that nothing can surpass human creativity.
This incident has added a layer of complexity to distinguishing between authentic and AI-generated photographs, following a similar case from the previous year where a photograph was disqualified for resembling AI creation, despite being captured using an iPhone.
TLDR: Photographer Miles Astray mistakenly submitted a genuine photograph in an AI-generated category, leading to the revocation of his awards by the competition organizers. The incident highlights the growing complexity in differentiating between authentic and AI-generated images in photography competitions.
Leave a Comment